Winnie helped the Tucks in the last section of the text.
Would you do what Winnie did? Why or why not?
Your response should be a well thought out short paragraph (4-5 sentences) free of spelling and grammar mistakes. I expect to see formal school language without texting-type language or symbols.
Stephanie-
ReplyDeleteyes i would of done what winnie did because she helped some one out that is a very kind thing to do. She did the right thing by helping tuck because tuck was really nice and kind to her all the time. He helped her out sometimes to. So yea i think that yes she did to a good thing by helping tuck out.
Adrianna Stevens:
ReplyDeleteWell of course i would've have done a brave and thoughtful risk like Winnie had done? Mae taught winnie how to feel the expression of love and happiness she als felt part of there family.
Daniel
ReplyDeleteI think Winnie did the right thing if everybodey else knew their problem they would understand why Winnie did it but if they also told them everybodey would rush to the spring but my final answer is yes i think she did the right thing.
Ryan
ReplyDeleteI wouldn't help Mea Tuck break out because I wouldn't want to get in trouble. Mea Tuck should of let winnie go back home when she wanted to. If Mea didn't hit the man in the yellow suit she would of been home.When ever someone comiits a crime I wouldn't help them I would just let them rot in jail.
Cesar:
ReplyDeleteYes, I would've saved Mae too because she was a very nice lady to Winnie. In my opinion Mae seemed to be a very nice person. Mae should not deserve to be hanged because she meant to save Winne not try to kill the man in the yellow suit. So yes I would've done the same thing like winnie did.
YULISSA:
ReplyDeleteYes,I would do what Winnie did because she helped someone in need, she helped her friends.I would do the same because as Winnie said the Tucks are friends and that's what friends do,they help each other out, they keep each others secrets and they also keep each other company in the good and bad times.I would also always know that what I did was a good thing to do even if it really was a bad thing to do,but you know what,I helped a friend and that's what friends are for.
I Anthony think that yes i would have done the same thing that winnie did because tuck is very nice to every one and tuck probably would have done the same thing winnie did if she needed help with some thing too.
ReplyDeleteAlexis
ReplyDeleteYes I would have done the same thing because i like to help those who need it. The Tucks have helped Winnie so why shouldnt she have done the same for them. The Tucks have helped her through the most hardest times. If Winnie had'nt helped them then that means that she doesnt appreciate what other people do for her. If a good friend came up to me told me to help them i would do it with pleasure, because in the past those friends have helped me to.
Trevor
ReplyDeleteYes i would of done the same thing winnie did because tucks was very nice to her. If it was anybody i would of done because it because I am that kind of person. I would provide help if anyone needed it. She did the right thing.
ALEX
ReplyDeleteYes, I think winnie did the right thing. The tucks were nice to her so in return she was very nice. I think winnie did the right thing because she is the reason the tucks are in this big problem. Winnie did the right by taking Mae's place in jail.
Yes, I would have done what Winnie did. I would have helped the Tuck's, because someone who barely knows you and helped you out with everything and was nice to you always then you whould have to repay them back by helping them out with a something.
ReplyDeleteBree A. Booth
I would do what winnie did because it would help out my friend escape from jail. Tuck and Mae liked her and protected her from the man in the yellow suit from taking her back to her house. Winnie wanted to help Mae escape from the jail house.
ReplyDeleteAndrea E.
keyla;)
ReplyDeleteIf i was in winnies place yes i would do what she did. i would do that because the tucks liked her and helped her and were very nice to her. i think it would be bad if she didn't help them out because they helped her out and they proved to her that they were there for her.so she should at least do something that shows the Tuck's that she is going to do the same thing and is going to be there when the Tuck's need her.....and I think that it is nice when you help someone out.
You bring up some interesting points. Adrianna you seem to really think deeply about what the underlying messages are in this novel.
ReplyDeleteRobert and Amy, you will need to retype your response following my directions.
Yes I would do what Winnie did because if she didnt the Tucks would have got caught and Mae would have died and Winnie would have felt horrible and she would have never for gave herself. So yeah i would do what winnie did in the epice rescue to save Mae Tuck from death.
ReplyDeleteTyson Esquerra
If I was in Winnies place I would have done the same thing she did. I would have done it because the person is my friend and the person isn't a bad person. plus I am pretty sure that the person i helped would have done the same thing for me if I was in Jail because of them. so what I am trying to say is that yes i would do the same thing winnie did.
ReplyDelete(:cecilia:)!!!<3
DEVIN:)
ReplyDeleteI would do what Winnie did she is a great friend to help the Tucks. I would help mae Tuck get out of the jailhouse. I would drink the water before seventeen. I would pretend to be Me since they helped out Winnie and gave her all that stuff. I would Help my friends to if they were in a jailhouse.
Dianna:
ReplyDeleteyes I would have done what winnie did because I would be helping some friends out. And if I loved them of couse I would help them out. Even if my parents got mad at me and not ever trust me again I would still do it. So yes I would do the same thing winne did.
Alec
ReplyDeleteI wouldn't help Mae get out because I would also get into trouble. I would also be involved with staying in jail just trying to get Mae out. I would just be home and say nothing and don't even think about it. I wouldn't get someone out of jail or even be there or else I'll be the one they are also looking for. So no, I wouldn't do what Winnie had did.
Marcus:
ReplyDeleteIf I was winne I would have helped Mae ecsape because she was my friend.I would also free her because she was one of my only friends.
Adrian
ReplyDeleteIf i was winnie i would do the same think. The reason that i would do the same thing is because they would have done the same thing for me. I would also do it because they are my friends and they're nice two me. And i would also do the same thing if the one i love is in the same place that they are and wouldn't let them be hung.
Jordan
ReplyDeleteno, because what if the Constable had caught them in the act? Than we all would be in trouble and than the Tuck's secret would be out and it would just cause anarchy, but otherwise no i wouldn't do what she did.I know the Tucks are good people but i wouldn't put my own life on the line.
Bryce
ReplyDeleteYes i would do what whinnie did because she helped some one she realy liked and i think its a bad thing to because what if winnie needs help and the tucks wont be there to help her if she gets into losts of big truble thats what i think about the question.
Adilene:)
ReplyDeleteYes i would done what winnie did because she did it because she likes the person. And maybe because when she needed help the tucks were there for her and it would look mean if she didn't help the tucks.
If I were in Winnnies place I would help the Tucks because they helped Winnie out and that would be nice to at least do something nice afer they helped Winnie through serious stuff. If winnie does really apreciate what they did to her she would hel them back. I would be nice and thankful to people that would help me and at least try to help them through hard times there passing. Noemi:)
ReplyDeleteNO I WOUND'T WANT TO DO WHAT WINNIE DID BECAUSE WHEN SHE TRADED PLACES WITH MAE SHE DIDN'T WANT TO GO TO SLEEP BECASUE SHE WAS AFRAID SH WAS GOING TO ROLL OVER OR FALL OFF THE BED, THEN WHEN SHE DOES THE CONSTABLES TO FIND OUT IT WAS HER. I WOULD WANT TO BECAUSE I MOVE AROUND IN BED, THEN WOULD IF I GET CAUGHT, MAN I WOULD BE UPSET...SO NO
ReplyDelete*MADOLYN BRENNER*
If i was winnie yes i would help the Tucks. I would help them because they did nothing wrong. If they told me a secrt like that then yes i would help them.I would also help them because they are my friends an i know if i help them it will help keep the secret so that no one eles will know.
ReplyDeleteDestinee hahah =>>>>>
Rocio:
ReplyDeleteYes,because it would be kind of me to do that. The tucks helped out winnie a lot and they like her, espesally jesse. Winnie had the courage to do what she did a the end of the story.
Mark $chifo
ReplyDeleteI would have done it then when the constable was not looking I would have made a run for it but I would have done it to help my friends. Im sure my friends would have done the same for me.
Nicolas
ReplyDeleteYes,because the tucks liked her and they helped her alot.If Winnie doesn't help the tucks i would say that it is not a very nice thing to do because they helped winnie alot.So it is time for her to help the tucks.So that winnie can thank them back for the help that the tucks gave her.
It kind of surprises me that so many of you would commit a criminal act to help a friend. If I'm ever in trouble, I hope I have good friends like you are all claiming to be.
ReplyDeleteterrible
ReplyDeletebe tddddddddddddddddddddddfacgvdjcbhldshcbhdsbjcgsdcvsdhgcvsdhgcvdgcvdgcvdgcvdgcvdgcvkjshdkjhsajhjdhalsdha
ReplyDeletesw4tyjnbvcdswertyujnbvcder567iknbvcdertyuiol,mnbvcfder5t678iokm vv d s
ReplyDelete